Drizzypedia

Best I Ever Had

From Drizzypedia, the Drake encyclopedia

Researched article42 references, about 10 min read

Read the lyrics
Contents
  1. Overview
  2. The beat
  3. What it says, and who it’s about
  4. From mixtape cut to single
  5. The video
  6. The Kia Shine dispute
  7. The Playboy lawsuit
  8. Charts, sales and awards
  9. On stage
  10. Versions and legacy
  11. Releases
  12. References

Overview

“Best I Ever Had” is the tenth track on So Far Gone, the mixtape Drake gave away on February 13, 2009, and the song that turned him from a Toronto actor with a blog following into a pop star. A mixtape cut with no label behind it, it climbed to No. 2 on the Billboard Hot 100, topped the R&B/Hip-Hop and rap charts, and became his first top-ten single.[1][17]

Boi-1da built the beat in about twenty minutes around the opening of a 1975 soft-rock hit, and Drake finished the song within hours. The record later brought a co-writing dispute with Memphis rapper Kia Shine, a copyright suit from Playboy Enterprises, a Kanye West-directed video, two Grammy nominations and, in 2025, an RIAA Diamond certification.[2][9][13][14][27][28]

The beat

Boi-1da (Matthew Samuels) made the beat in December 2008 or January 2009, while Drake was finishing So Far Gone and asking for two more songs. He was still living in his parents’ basement. A friend had handed him a folder of old-school samples, and in it he found “Fallin’ in Love” by Hamilton, Joe Frank & Reynolds. He chopped its intro into the whole track, liking that it sounded smoother and moved faster than his usual work.[2][3]

He says he heard it as a song about a girl, with an emotional mood that might suit Drake. He sent it the next day to Drake, who was on the road with Lil Wayne at the time and not in the studio with him. Drake wrote and recorded the song within a few hours, and in Boi-1da’s words he “killed it.” Boi-1da had just quit his job. He later called it the life-changing record that got people to take his craft seriously, though he says he had never had a hit and didn’t predict how big it would be.[2][3]

Noah “40” Shebib recorded and mixed it, as he did most of the tape. Wikipedia lists the length at about 4:16 to 4:19 depending on the release, at roughly 107 beats per minute. It also lists a second source alongside the soft-rock sample: “Do It for the Boy,” a Lil Wayne mixtape song. That is where the Kia Shine dispute begins (below).[1]

The sampled song is no obscurity. “Fallin’ in Love” came out on May 2, 1975, was written by Dan Hamilton, and went to No. 1 on the Hot 100. It was the only pop No. 1 Playboy Records ever had, which is why Playboy, not a music publisher, ended up suing Drake.[12]

Nickelus F, who had collaborated with Drake since they met on MySpace, was asked by Complex in February 2010 about rumours that he ghostwrote for Drake. He said he had written one verse on the retail version of So Far Gone, which he would not name, and specifically denied any involvement with “Best I Ever Had.”[41]

What it says, and who it’s about

The song opens with a spoken aside, Drake noting that a lot of women assume his songs are about them. The rest is addressed to one unnamed woman in the second person. It swings between tender compliments and bragging, sung and rapped in the same breath. The hook’s best-known image praises her at her least glamorous: dressed down, hair tied back, no makeup.[26][1]

Along the way Drake claims to be on the same “sex, love and pain” wavelength as the R&B singer Tank, a nod to Tank’s 2007 album Sex, Love & Pain, as Rolling Stone points out. He also borrowed a line from a Lil Wayne song, which he admitted himself during the Kia Shine dispute.[23][8]

Years later Drake named the woman behind it. On Toronto radio station Flow 93.5, he said the song was about an ex he called Nebby, a woman who in his words “represented everything about the city that I loved.” American Songwriter dates that interview to November 2011, reports that he called her the best woman he had ever had, and says he referenced her again on Take Care’s “Look What You’ve Done.”[21][22]

Fan theory Many fans believe the same woman is behind “Hotline Bling” (2015). Drake has not said so.[22]

Interpretation Read against the opening aside, the reveal is a small joke on his listeners: the song that tells women not to assume they’re the subject did have one subject. Nylon makes a broader point, that Drake’s early love songs say less about the women than about the places, Toronto above all, that they stand for.[21]

From mixtape cut to single

Drake didn’t pick it as the single. In a Rap Radar interview released on Christmas Day 2019, he said he wanted “Uptown” with Bun B and Lil Wayne to lead So Far Gone (“‘Uptown’ is the one”), and that LeBron James’s agent and close friend Rich Paul talked him out of it. The exchange is around the 13-minute mark.[4][5]

Radio found the song anyway. The FADER’s September 2009 cover story describes a soft-rock-sampling mixtape track hitting No. 1 on chart after chart with no major label and no record deal behind it.[17]

Before Drake could sell it, someone else did. On May 28, 2009, a company called Canadian Money Entertainment, founded by Peter Greenwood, put an unauthorized album called The Girls Love Drake on iTunes, Rhapsody and Amazon through the distributor IODA, built from So Far Gone songs and others. Downloads pushed “Best I Ever Had” from No. 60 to No. 18 on the Hot 100, and “Every Girl” from No. 75 to No. 35. Drake’s manager Al Branch called it “a straight bootleg, a scandal” and sent a cease-and-desist. iTunes pulled the album, and Drake’s camp said it planned to sue. Greenwood told Billboard he meant no harm and hadn’t known about the legal problems with selling mixtapes.[6][1]

The official single reached iTunes in mid-June. Oliver El-Khatib announced it on October’s Very Own on June 18, 2009, with artwork by Darkie. According to Wikipedia, iTunes rejected Darkie’s first cover, a plain design on white, as too generic, and he made a new one.[7][1]

The deal followed the hit. Young Money confirmed Drake as its newest signing on June 29, 2009. The FADER reported that he signed through Aspire, a company co-run by his manager Cortez Bryant, with distribution through Universal Republic, after a bidding war that included Atlantic and Interscope.[39][17]

The video

Kanye West directed the video in Brooklyn in June 2009, at Bishop Ford Central Catholic High School. XXL broke the news on June 15, citing an inside source who described a Degrassi theme, a nod to the teen drama Drake starred in before music. The production company was Ghost Town Media, with Justin Benoliel producing and Derek Lee editing.[14][1][16]

Drake plays the coach of a women’s basketball team that loses 91–14 to a taller, fitter opponent, and he ends the video dejected in his office. A clip ran on MTV’s It’s On with Alexa Chung on June 30, the full video premiered online on July 1, and AMTV aired it on July 2. Trey Songz, Fabolous, Consequence and Boi-1da make cameos, along with Young Money’s Lil Twist, Shanell and Lil Chuckee.[1][20]

One of the team captains was played by an aspiring actress credited only as Shakur, who worked with will.i.am. She told XXL that West called her himself to say she would be right for it, and that she got to improvise on camera with Drake. Before the premiere, XXL listed Lil Wayne and Common in the cast and said Jay-Z was on set. Neither report confirmed that any of them appear in the finished cut.[15][14]

The video split opinion. The Guardian’s Anna Pickard criticized how it leered at the players’ bodies, and The FADER’s cover story said its jokey tone undercut the sincerity of the hook, to the disappointment of some young fans. Drake told The FADER the choice was deliberate. He wanted something crazy enough to offend people and break the “pretty boy” pattern his label pushed (“Man, let’s do Kanye’s video”). He also said West called to tell him he had re-edited it.[19][17]

Drake never backed away from it. Asked about his videos in a November 2011 Complex interview, he named it his favorite: “That’s a genius video.”[18]

The Kia Shine dispute

In September 2009, after the BMI Awards on September 10, reports said Memphis rapper and producer Kia Shine had received three BMI awards for a writing credit on the song. Kia Shine said he had made the beat and hook for “Do It for the Boy,” which he shared with Lil Wayne in March 2008. He also said Universal Music Group had agreed he was owed 25 percent. SOHH reported him saying Drake took the melody, some of the words and the cadence.[1][10]

Drake answered on his October’s Very Own blog on September 17. He said he had never met or worked with Kia Shine, called the 25 percent claims false, and said he “wrote the entire composition in Toronto.” He conceded that he borrowed a single line from a Lil Wayne song whose beat Kia Shine produced. Kia Shine posted photos of his plaques and told Angela Yee he was only explaining what happened.[8][1]

Song-credit listings now include Kia Shine’s legal name, Nakia Coleman, among the writers, alongside Drake (Aubrey Graham), Boi-1da (Matthew Samuels), Lil Wayne (Dwayne Carter) and the sampled song’s writer Danny Hamilton. According to Wikipedia, BMI gave Kia Shine another award for the song in September 2010.[26][11]

In an interview on The GAUDS Show, resurfaced in June 2024, Kia Shine said that when the two later ran into each other, it was “all good.”[9]

The Playboy lawsuit

On June 24, 2010, Playboy Enterprises sued Drake, Cash Money Records and Universal Music Group for copyright infringement over the use of “Fallin’ in Love.” It said it had suffered and would keep suffering irreparable injury, asked for all infringing copies to be recalled and destroyed, and argued that each defendant knew or should have known the recording was copyrighted. The case was settled by 2012 for an undisclosed amount.[1][13]

Charts, sales and awards

The song peaked at No. 2 on the Hot 100, Drake’s first top-ten single as a lead artist. It went to No. 1 on Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs and Hot Rap Tracks and reached No. 49 on the Pop 100. It finished 2009 at No. 79 on the Hot 100 year-end chart, No. 4 on the year-end rap chart and No. 1 on the year-end Rhythmic chart. Wikipedia credits it with making Drake the first Canadian rapper to top the R&B/Hip-Hop and rap charts at the same time, and the second Canadian artist to top R&B/Hip-Hop after Deborah Cox. It stayed his highest-charting lead single until “One Dance” reached No. 1 in 2016.[1]

The single sold more than 300,000 copies in its first two weeks on iTunes and passed two million downloads by December 2010. The RIAA certified it 4× Platinum on June 29, 2018, the day Scorpion was released. On May 28, 2025, it was certified Diamond (ten million units), together with “Hold On, We’re Going Home.” That gave Drake ten Diamond certifications, the most of any artist.[1][30][28][29]

At the 52nd Grammy Awards on January 31, 2010, the song was nominated for Best Rap Solo Performance and Best Rap Song. It lost both to Jay-Z, to “D.O.A. (Death of Auto-Tune)” and to “Run This Town.” At the 2010 Juno Awards it was nominated for Single of the Year and lost to Michael Bublé’s “Haven’t Met You Yet.”[27][1]

On stage

Drake tore his ACL, MCL and LCL playing basketball in June 2009, the same month the basketball-themed video was shot. At the BET Awards that month, he performed “Best I Ever Had” and “Every Girl” with Lil Wayne sitting down.[35][31]

Against his doctors’ advice he joined Young Money’s America’s Most Wanted tour. Before the tour he told MTV he had to be cautious, because a second tear might stop him from walking. On Friday, July 31, 2009, at the Susquehanna Bank Center in Camden, New Jersey, he tried to spin while performing the song with Wayne, collapsed, and was carried off while Wayne finished it alone.[32][33][31]

On his blog, Drake wrote that he had started the tour with a “torn ACL, MCL, and LCL” and didn’t know what new damage he had done. He made a surprise appearance at the Toronto stop on August 4, then left the tour for surgery in Toronto, and Pleasure P and Jeremih filled in.[34][36]

Versions and legacy

The song was reissued on the So Far Gone EP (September 15, 2009) and added as a bonus track to some international editions of Thank Me Later (2010). In the UK it was released as a double A-side with “Fancy.” Nicki Minaj, then Drake’s Young Money labelmate, put her own version with his vocals on Beam Me Up Scotty in April 2009. It returned when that tape was reissued on May 14, 2021.[1][39]

Critics caught the song’s two registers from the start. Pitchfork’s Tom Breihan called it a “Nerf-heavy declaration of lust,” and the Christian review site Plugged In argued that its romantic sentiments are really a prelude to sexual daydreaming. Later lists treat it as the hinge of his career. USA Today ranked it No. 4 among his best songs in 2018, The Ringer put it at No. 9 of nearly 190 that year, and Rolling Stone’s 100 Best Drake Songs puts it at No. 25, calling it the hit that made him a star.[24][25][37][38][23]

Interpretation Its lasting influence is the blend. One verse can be soft and boastful, sung and rapped, sincere and crude. That mix, delivered over a sample older than Drake, became the template for nearly everything he did next.[38][23]

Places to dig further: the 24-minute podcast episode “We Could Do it Real Big” (February 2024), which uses unearthed MuchMusic audio alongside Rap Radar, MTV News, Myspace and CBS News sound; Drake’s Rap Radar interview (December 2019, from 13:00); Boi-1da’s two beat breakdowns for Complex (2010) and DJBooth (2018); and Drake’s “Angels and Demons” blog post from August 2009.[40][4][2][3][34]

Releases

References

  1. Best I Ever Had (Drake song)Wikipedia
  2. Boi-1da Tells All: The Stories Behind His Biggest Hits (Insanul Ahmed, May 12, 2010)Complex
  3. Beat Break: Boi-1da Shares the Story Behind His 5 Biggest Songs (Feb 2018)DJBooth
  4. Drake Says Rich Paul Convinced Him to Release "Best I Ever Had" as First Single (Joe Price, Dec 27, 2019)Complex
  5. Drake Claims LeBron James’ Agent Rich Paul Convinced Him to Release "Best I Ever Had" (Dec 2019)XXL
  6. Exclusive: Fake Drake Album Sold On iTunes, Lawsuit Planned Against Label (June 2009)Billboard
  7. Best I Ever Had Now on iTunes (Oliver El-Khatib, June 18, 2009)October's Very Own
  8. Best I Ever Had (Drake’s statement on Kia Shine, Sept 17, 2009)October's Very Own
  9. Kia Shine Reveals How He Co-Wrote Drake’s "Best I Ever Had" (Cole Blake, June 26, 2024)HotNewHipHop
  10. Kia Shine Stands By His Word (Cyrus Langhorne, Sept 18, 2009; archived)SOHH
  11. Kia ShineWikipedia
  12. Fallin' in Love (Hamilton, Joe Frank & Reynolds song)Wikipedia
  13. Playboy to sue Drake for copyright infringement (Sean Michaels, June 29, 2010)The Guardian
  14. Kanye West Steps Behind The Camera For New Drake Video (June 15, 2009)XXL
  15. "Best I Ever Had" Lead Speaks on Being Drake’s Main Squeeze (June 26, 2009)XXL
  16. WATCH IT: Drake "Best I Ever Had" (video credits)Videostatic
  17. Cover Story: Drake’s Rise to Fame and Fortune (Edwin "Stats" Houghton, Sept 1, 2009)The FADER
  18. Cover Story Uncut: Drake Talks About Romance, Rap, And What’s Really Real (Damien Scott, Nov 15, 2011)Complex
  19. Drake – The Best I Ever Had (Anna Pickard, July 9, 2009)The Guardian
  20. Drake "Best I Ever Had" Video by Kanye West (Eugene Kan, July 2009)Hypebeast
  21. A History Of Drake’s Complicated Relationship With Women (Grant Rindner, Apr 11, 2017)Nylon
  22. The Meaning Behind Drake’s "Hotline Bling"American Songwriter
  23. The 100 Best Drake Songs (Mosi Reeves; No. 25)Rolling Stone Australia
  24. Drake: So Far Gone (Tom Breihan, June 29, 2009)Pitchfork
  25. "Best I Ever Had" track review (Adam R. Holz)Plugged In
  26. "Best I Ever Had" by Drake: lyrics, meaning and creditsSongMeaningsAndFacts
  27. 52nd Annual Grammy Awards RecapHipHopWired
  28. Drake Earns Record-Breaking 10th RIAA Diamond Certification (May 2025)Stereogum
  29. Drake Makes RIAA History After Earning Two New Diamond Certifications (May 29, 2025)Power 105.1 / iHeart
  30. 55 Drake Songs Hit Platinum Status (June 29, 2018)XXL
  31. Drake: "Lord only knows what other damage I have done" (Aug 2009)AllHipHop
  32. Drake Collapses During Live Show (July 31, 2009)Rap-Up
  33. Rapper Drake Collapses On Stage (Aug 2009)Access
  34. Drake Lines Up Surgery for ACL, Pleasure P, Jeremih Fill In on Tour (Aug 2009)Rolling Stone
  35. When Rappers Get Hurt From Accidents (June 2011)Complex
  36. Rapper Drake pulls out of Lil Wayne show at Montreal Bell Centre (Montreal Gazette, Aug 5, 2009)degrassi.ca
  37. Drake, definitively: His 25 best songs, ranked (USA Today, July 24, 2018)PressReader
  38. Every Drake Song, Ranked (July 4, 2018)The Ringer
  39. King in the North: a Drake timeline (Erin Lowers, Mar 29, 2016)Exclaim!
  40. We Could Do it Real Big: The True Story of Drake’s "Best I Ever Had" (podcast episode, Feb 15, 2024)Everand
  41. Interview: Nickelus F Talks Exterminator Day Job, Discovering Portishead, & Writing For Drake (Toshitaka Kondo, Feb 11, 2010)Complex
  42. Release listing for So Far Gonemusic.apple.com