Drizzypedia

Truffle Butter

From Drizzypedia, the Drake encyclopedia

Researched article15 references, about 3 min read

Read the lyrics
Contents
  1. Overview
  2. “Whatcha Say”: the beat’s first life
  3. The Maya Jane Coles sample
  4. The verses
  5. Reception
  6. Releases
  7. References

Overview

“Truffle Butter” is a song by Nicki Minaj featuring Drake and Lil Wayne, first released as an iTunes-exclusive bonus track on her album The Pinkprint in December 2014. It became a single on January 23, 2015, and went to urban and pop radio on March 2 and 3. Nineteen85 and Maya Jane Coles are credited as producers, and the writers are Onika Maraj, Aubrey Graham, Dwayne Carter, Paul Jefferies (Nineteen85) and Coles. It runs 3:40 and is built on Coles’ 2010 deep-house track “What They Say.”[1][14]

Without a chorus or a music video, it peaked at No. 14 on the Hot 100, No. 4 on Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs and No. 2 on Hot Rap Songs, and reached No. 1 on Rhythmic radio. It was Drake’s 74th Hot 100 entry, tying Ray Charles for sixth-most at the time. It went Platinum in Australia and New Zealand and Gold in the UK, and was nominated for Best Rap Performance at the 58th Grammy Awards.[1]

“Whatcha Say”: the beat’s first life

Drake’s verse was heard before Minaj’s song existed publicly. In September 2014, “Whatcha Say,” a track credited to The K.I.D. Heat and Mally Mall featuring Drake and Tyga, premiered live on Power 106. It used the same instrumental and the same Drake verse that later appeared on “Truffle Butter.”[2][1]

Minaj told the story on BBC Radio 1Xtra in March 2015. The song was meant for her album but somehow ended up with Tyga. She told him it was hers and that she and Drake would be on it, and asked him not to put it out, but it leaked with his version anyway. She felt disrespected because she had always shown him love. She said Tyga later texted an apology and they had worked things out. Wikipedia adds that Tyga got the song after Drake had already recorded his verse, and that Tyga added a verse of his own and a hook from Mally Mall.[8][9][10][1]

Interpretation When The Pinkprint leaked in December, XXL read “Truffle Butter” in light of Tyga’s beef with Drake and suggested Tyga had been iced out of tracks with him.[3]

The Maya Jane Coles sample

Nineteen85 found “What They Say” by chance while scrolling YouTube, according to DJ Mag; Songfacts cites him telling Billboard the same. DJ Mag describes the finished beat as a lightly enhanced version of Coles’ original, without the snares, claps and 808 bass typical of rap, so it sits closer to house than hip-hop. Complex heard a slowed-down sample.[13][14][4]

When The Pinkprint leaked in mid-December 2014, house fans recognized the record immediately. Coles posted on Facebook that she was excited to be involved, while some of her own listeners objected. Dancing Astronaut called it a rare crossover for underground house, and Complex joked that everyone had heard “What They Say” by then, Drake, Wayne and Minaj included.[5][4][7][6]

Coles later said she was a fan of the song. She told Billboard in 2017 that she approved the sample because it brought listeners to her other music and to electronic music more broadly, and that the only criticism she got came mostly from older men. In the DJ Mag history of the track, she called it her favorite reworking of “What They Say,” said Minaj’s team handled it well, and said she was surprised it became a single since she had only signed off on a sample. Billboard linked the song’s success to her signing with EMI as a producer, and Beatportal noted the lyric video had nearly 39 million views by 2020.[11][13][12]

The verses

All three rappers open their verses with “thinkin’ out loud,” which The Guardian’s Alex Macpherson heard as a relaxed, spontaneous mode (as cited on Wikipedia). Songfacts describes all three bragging about their accomplishments. Minaj said on 1Xtra that it was made for the streets and for the love of it, with no real plan for a video.[1][14][8]

Reception

Interpretation Critics often preferred it to “Only,” the album’s other song with Drake and Wayne. Wikipedia collects the praise: Pitchfork’s Meaghan Garvey called it an easy radio hit, far more likable than “Only,” and was puzzled that it was only a bonus track. Complex’s Anupa Mistry called it a brilliant moment, SPIN’s Brennan Carley a surefire hit, and Slate’s Dee Lockett compared its appeal to “Super Bass.” Stereogum’s Tom Breihan praised its tastefully glimmering sound, called it the catchiest chorus-less song since Bobby Shmurda’s breakout, and said Cash Money would be foolish not to make it a single.[1]

Its success came without a full music video. A lyric video directed and animated by Zi9mortius premiered March 10, 2015. Rappers including Ludacris, Ace Hood, T.I. and Fat Trel recorded their own versions over the beat. Drake performed it on his Would You Like a Tour? dates in Australia in February 2015, and Minaj kept it in her Pinkprint Tour set.[1][8]

Releases

References

  1. Truffle ButterWikipedia
  2. Drake And Tyga Jump On The K.I.D Heat And Mally Mall’s ‘Whatcha Say’ (Sep 4, 2014)Capital XTRA
  3. Nicki Minaj’s Album ‘The Pinkprint’ Leaks (Marvin Jules, Dec 11, 2014)XXL
  4. Maya Jane Coles Was Sampled on Nicki Minaj’s New Album (Dec 11, 2014)Complex
  5. Maya Jane Coles track sampled in latest Nicki Minaj single, responds to reaction (Steph Evans, Dec 11, 2014)EARMILK
  6. Maya Jane Coles’ “What They Say” Got Sampled On A Nicki Minaj Track (James Keith, Dec 12, 2014)Complex
  7. Nicki Minaj samples Maya Jane Coles for evocative single ‘Truffle Butter’ (Dan Roy Carter, Dec 12, 2014)Dancing Astronaut
  8. Nicki Minaj Felt Disrespected By Tyga Over “Truffle Butter” Leak (Trevor Smith, Mar 5, 2015)HotNewHipHop
  9. Nicki Minaj Says She Felt Disrespected by Tyga Over “Truffle Butter” (Shawn Christ, Mar 5, 2015)Music Times
  10. Nicki Minaj Explains Why Tyga Isn’t On “Truffle Butter” (Mar 5, 2015)Hip-Hop Wired
  11. ‘Take Flight’ With Maya Jane Coles: Producer Reflects (Annabel Ross, Sep 21, 2017)Billboard
  12. Maya Jane Coles’ Uncompromising Attitude is The Key to Her Success (Mar 2020)Beatportal
  13. How Maya Jane Coles’ ‘What They Say’ became the backbone of major pop hits (Katherine Rogers)DJ Mag
  14. Truffle Butter by Nicki Minaj (featuring Drake & Lil Wayne)Songfacts
  15. Release listing for The Pinkprintmusic.apple.com