When to Say When
From Drizzypedia, the Drake encyclopedia
Researched article19 references, about 3 min read
Contents
Overview
“When to Say When” is a “life talk” rap by Drake, built on the same Bobby Glenn soul sample that Just Blaze used for Jay-Z’s “Song Cry.” He released it just before midnight on February 29, 2020, as half of a two-pack with “Chicago Freestyle,” on SoundCloud and in a shared Theo Skudra video. In the Brooklyn-set first half of the video he visits Jay-Z’s Marcy Projects. The song was produced by June James, with Drake’s personal trainer Roxx earning his first credit. It became the second track on Dark Lane Demo Tapes and peaked at No. 35 on the Billboard Hot 100.[3][4][1][15][10][2]
Release
Drake announced the drop on Instagram with both covers and a caption pointing fans to “new full Drake 2020 leaks” on OVO’s SoundCloud. Complex’s Eric Skelton got the alert at 11:23 p.m. that Saturday. Rolling Stone noted that the four-minute video used shortened versions of both songs, with the full tracks on SoundCloud only, not on streaming services. Highsnobiety wondered whether they were album cuts or loosies. Rolling Stone and The Line of Best Fit called them his first solo songs of 2020, after “Life Is Good” and “Desires” with Future.[3][4][7][8][9]
Skelton linked the song to Drake’s December 2019 Rap Radar interview. There Drake told Elliott Wilson and B.Dot about an unreleased “life talk” track he had sent them, to show he could still rap. In the same interview Drake said every album has to satisfy two audiences: listeners who want singing, and those who want bars.[4]
Sample and production
The writing credits include Bobby Glenn and Ralph Johnson for the sampled “Sounds Like a Love Song.” Songfacts dates it to 1976, and Jay-Z had built “Song Cry” on it in 2001. June James, a Houston producer signed to Think It’s a Game Entertainment, produced the track. Alonzo “Roxx” Thornhill and AJ Costly are credited as additional producers. Variety identified Roxx as a Montreal native and former rapper who had become Drake’s personal trainer. Noah “40” Shebib mixed the track.[1][14][10]
Interpretation Okayplayer’s Andre Gee read the choice as a homage. To him Drake, then 33, was re-exploring a Jay-Z record the way older generations revisit their own classics, a nod to a hip-hop canon he hoped to join. He noted that June James retweeted a fan who called “Song Cry” one of the great samples.[15]
What he raps
Interpretation Skelton heard the song mix chart-record boasts and comparisons to Michael Jackson with more natural lines about fatherhood. Large parts deal with rivals and his place in rap’s pecking order as a new decade began. TIME noted a shout-out to his mother, Sandi Graham. Skelton argued that Drake delivered vulnerable material here with more confidence than his earlier, sometimes mopey life-talk songs. He saw the release as a bid to win over core hip-hop fans who still doubted him as a rapper.[4][11]
Two lines drew backlash. One pairs Michael Jackson with a “palace” not meant for kids. Capital XTRA reported that Jackson fans called it disrespectful, reading it as a reference to Neverland and the abuse allegations against him. HotNewHipHop noted that other listeners heard wordplay in which Drake defended himself against rumours. Capital XTRA said Drake had not responded. Another line called Sophie Brussaux, the mother of his son, a fluke while saying he loves her for who she is. Some fans found it dismissive, while others defended the word choice.[16][18][17]
Brooklyn video
Skudra’s Brooklyn half follows Drake through the Diamond District, across the Brooklyn Bridge and into the Marcy Projects, where Complex noted he had been spotted filming in early February. It also shows him at his jeweler previewing new pieces and in a studio session with 40. Stereogum and Rolling Stone tied the Marcy stop to Jay-Z. The video then cuts to Toronto for “Chicago Freestyle.”[8][6][7][4][5]
Reception and charts
Interpretation According to Wikipedia’s summary of Pitchfork, Sheldon Pearce’s mixed review of the two-pack argued that Drake did not play the heel nearly as well as Eminem had in 2002. Skelton saw both tracks as non-commercial releases meant to make a point rather than chase hits. In reviews of the mixtape, Rolling Stone’s Danny Schwartz heard it flip the melodrama of the “Song Cry” sample into Drake’s pain-focused mood. NME’s Luke Morgan Britton, otherwise unimpressed with the tape, called it classic-sounding but resonant, Drake at his best when inspired.[1][4][12][13]
After Dark Lane Demo Tapes put it on streaming services, the song reached No. 35 on the Hot 100, No. 38 in Canada and No. 151 in France. It missed the UK Singles Chart because of the rule limiting an artist to three songs in the top 100 at once, but reached No. 47 on the UK streaming chart.[2]
Releases
- Dark Lane Demo TapesMixtape, May 1, 2020, track 2[19]
References
- Dark Lane Demo TapesWikipedia
- Drake singles discographyWikipedia
- Drake Drops New Songs “When to Say When” and “Chicago Freestyle” (C. Vernon Coleman II, Mar 1, 2020)XXL
- First Impressions of Drake’s New Songs “When to Say When” and “Chicago Freestyle” (Eric Skelton, Mar 1, 2020)Complex
- Drake Drops Video for New Songs “When to Say When” and “Chicago Freestyle” (Eric Diep, Mar 1, 2020)Complex
- Drake – “When To Say When” & “Chicago Freestyle” (James Rettig, Mar 1, 2020)Stereogum
- Drake Drops Video for New Songs ‘When to Say When,’ ‘Chicago Freestyle’ (Daniel Kreps, Mar 2, 2020)Rolling Stone Australia
- Drake Just Surprise Dropped Two New Songs, Stream Here (Sarah Osei, Mar 2, 2020)Highsnobiety
- Drake returns with new tracks “When To Say When” and “Chicago Freestyle” (Cerys Kenneally, Mar 2, 2020)The Line of Best Fit
- Every Producer Who Worked on Drake’s ‘Dark Lane Demo Tapes’ (Shirley Ju, May 3, 2020)Variety
- The 6 Biggest Takeaways From Drake’s New Mixtape Dark Lane Demo Tapes (Andrew R. Chow & Cady Lang, May 1, 2020)TIME
- Drake’s ‘Dark Lane Demo Tapes’ Might Be His Gloomiest Release Ever (Danny Schwartz, May 4, 2020)Rolling Stone
- Drake – ‘Dark Lane Demo Tapes’ review (Luke Morgan Britton, May 1, 2020)NME
- When to Say When by DrakeSongfacts
- Early 2000s Hip-Hop & R&B is Defining Modern Rap (Andre Gee; first published March 2020)Okayplayer
- Drake dragged over “disrespectful” Michael Jackson lyric in controversial new song (Mar 2, 2020)Capital XTRA
- Drake slammed by fans after branding baby mama Sophie Brussaux a “fluke” on new song (Mar 3, 2020)Capital XTRA
- Drake Gets Dragged Online For Michael Jackson Lyric In New Song (Karlton Jahmal, Mar 1, 2020)HotNewHipHop
- Release listing for Dark Lane Demo Tapesopen.spotify.com
